|
E-commerce is one of the buzz-words of the new millennium.
If you believe the spoutings of the industry pundits, the
very future of Oxford Street is at stake. But what is e-commerce?
Is it really something to get excited or concerned about,
depending on your level of technophobia? This section of our
website will give you a brief introduction to the issues and
key principles.
Electronic (hence the "e") commerce is basically
buying and selling over the Internet. Nowadays, you can buy
almost anything you want on-line: insurance, holidays, houses,
books, CDs; the list is endless, and growing. There are benefits
to both the seller and buyer.
The seller can cut out the middle-man (or distribution chain)
and has no need for show-rooms. One of the world's leading
car manufacturers intends to be selling all its cars on-line
within ten years. All its cars will be made to order, it will
not have to build a batch which waits in a car park until
chosen by customers.
The buyer has a wider choice of goods. For example, Amazon.com
(the major Internet bookseller) has a catalogue of millions
of books, far more comprehensive than the local bookstore.
Because there is no middle-man, the goods are invariably cheaper,
although delivery costs lessen the bargain. Currently, the
buyer can also save on tax (though this is likely to change
in the near future as Governments like to get their tax!)
So, e-commerce seems to be a winner on both fronts. However,
there are legal implications for both the seller and the buyer
which should be considered. There follows a brief overview
of some of the issues to consider if trading or buying over
the Internet.
Issues for the Seller
Jurisdiction
As soon as you trade on-line, you are effectively
trading internationally. Your site can be accessed by users
in other jurisdictions. The issue here is that different jurisdictions
have very different rules and regulations and you will need
to ensure you do not fall foul of them. Certain special offers,
for example, which are common in the UK, are illegal in continental
Europe and elsewhere.
Security
There has been much publicity questioning whether
e-commerce is sufficiently secure. It can be, but it is important
to take appropriate precautions. A linked point is to ensure
you have appropriate virus checks. You don't want your site
to contain damaging viruses.
Advertising restrictions
As noted above, by going international, you are subject
to different international advertising regulations. Some major
companies have fallen foul of these regulations simply by
failing to consider the international implications of trading
on-line.
Data Protection
It is inevitable that you will be accepting personal
information on customers. Consequently if you have a UK base,
you will be subject to UK data protection laws, which are
(or soon will be) common throughout the EU. You will also
need to ensure you have the appropriate registrations.
Libel/defamation
You will need to be careful if you are allowing others
to "post" comments or information on your website.
A recent case ("Demon") has demonstrated that the
website host may be liable for defamatory statements placed
on his website.
Governing terms
It will be important to have your terms of trade clearly
set out on the website, with the need for the user to read
and acknowledge acceptance before proceeding. This is essential
to ensure your terms are incorporated into the contract.
New Law
There will be new UK and EC law on e-commerce, particularly
relating to electronic signatures and the provision of encryption
serves. There are also proposals relating to distance selling
and the establishment of e-commerce codes for consumer transactions
and an "e-hallmark" for use by recognised/legitimate
traders. The Electronic Communications Act finally came into
force on 25th May 2000. Please see 'Recent Initiatives' for
a summary of the Act, together with consideration of the Regulation
of Investigatory Powers Bill and the EC Distance Selling Directive.
Issues for the Buyer
Security
One of the major concerns voiced with regard to e-commerce
is on security. The majority of e-commerce financial transactions
are by credit card. A number of sites accept telephone purchases
but an increasing number are now requiring that credit card
details be processed on-line. Is this safe? With the skills
of hackers, credit card details can be intercepted and used
for fraudulent purposes. There are risks, but there are also
risks of fraudulent misuse when details are given in telephone
transactions and when cards are taken out of sight for processing
in restaurants. In practice, no system is risk-free but the
use of encryption (link to cybercrime) minimises the chances
of interception.
Jurisdiction
This is the same issue as for the seller. How do you
know which country's laws will regulate the trade in the event
of a dispute with an overseas supplier? What if it is not
even clear from the website in which country the seller is
based? Basically, there is the risk (though this is no different
from any mail-order service) that you will not receive the
goods, or that they are defective, that you cannot trace or
identify the seller or that you will not have an effective
remedy in an overseas jurisdiction.
Tax
One of the perceived advantages about e-commerce is
the avoidance of certain tax charges. However, this is unlikely
to remain the case long-term. Changes are likely to be introduced
in the near future, and it is likely that consumers will find
that tax laws adapt to the new means of trade.
Summary
We hope that this is of some use if you are considering
trading or purchasing goods on the Internet. As with all areas
of Internet law, the rules regarding e-commerce are constantly
evolving and subject to revision and update. At Charles Russell,
we have much experience in dealing with e-commerce and can
confidently guide you through the problems involved. If you
would like further information, please contact David
Berry or Robin
Bynoe
|